How to increase the return of an investment property to more than 20%?

by ongkl · 35 comments

in Top Post, case study, finance, investment theory, market, real estate tips

4820sri_wangi-1-large448x336

We have acquired a rental apartment at the price of RM125,000 in end of last year 2008. The apartment was rented out in March 2009 before the completion of its furnishing work. Its monthly rent is RM1300. Initial annual return of this property was 8.54%. Later in this article we will show you how we increase its return to more than 20%.

A bad start
This is a 3-bedroom apartment located in Tampoi with amenities like swimming pool, gym, 24-hour security, badminton, basketball and tennis courts. The apartment’s name is Sri Wangi and the unit that we acquired is on the 4th floor.

We signed a sale and purchase agreement (SPA) with the vendor of this property in November 2008. However, due to the delay in loan application during the holiday season of December 2008, we decided to pay cash to buy this property. We managed to get the keys of the property in end of February 2009.

It was a bad start to us because we planned to finance this purchase. Using cash to buy a property is never our first choice because all properties that we acquired are properties that worth borrowing based on our analysis. (Read “Why you want to take up a loan for your real estate investment?” to find out what is a property that worth borrowing and how such property can give you the maximum return.)

We expected to rent the apartment for a monthly rent of RM1200 with fully furnished condition. We allocated RM15,000 for the furnishing cost. Estimated legal and brokerage fees were about RM7600. Management fee of the apartment with quit rent and assessment was around RM150 every month.

From the analysis using our property evaluation spreadsheet (which you can download it free by subscribing to our newsletter) as shown in the following table, the property would bring us monthly cash flow of RM1050 if we successfully rented it out for RM1200. We expected the annual return (cashflow yield) to be 8.54% if we used cash to acquire it.
cashflow-projection-cash1

RM1050 is quite a good cash flow but when we compare it with the total cash capital that we were required to put in (RM147,500), 8.54% is really not an attractive figure. We need at least 11.7 years to take back all the cash capital.

Take a look at the spreadsheet if we financed this acquisition. We could expect a return of 18.14% if we managed to borrow 90% of the purchase price from bank for a tenure of 30 years with interest rate 3.75% (see table below). This mean we would be able to take back our cash capital, which would be RM35,000 only in this case, within 6 years!
cashflow-projection-finance2

Turning bad luck into good luck
Although the expected return dropped significantly compared to the case if we financed the purchase, we decided to carry on with our plan to increase the value of this property – to furnish the apartment with the allocated budget.

During the week when furnishing work was undergoing in March, several prospective tenants were brought by our property agent to view the apartment. Two of them liked the apartment very much. One offered RM1200 while the other offered RM1300. We chose the latter.

The main reason why our apartment could be easily rented out even before we finished the furnishing work was that we had a reasonable budget for quality furnishing work. With that budget, we were able to use quality paint and purchase new lightings, furniture, electrical appliances and air-conditioner for the apartment.

Though simple designed and configured (see figure below), tenants like our way of preparing the best for whoever is going to stay in the apartment.
img_0117448x336

We were not happy, yet, with the RM100 more–than-expected rent. We negotiated and asked for discounts from lawyer, agents and contractors. We managed to reduce the furnishing cost, legal and brokerage fees to RM14,000 and RM5700 respectively.

Not only that, we are now going to finance this apartment. The tenancy agreement signed in the middle of March 2009 now becomes a very strong supporting document to prove its increased value to the banks since the apartment is generating income by itself.

Marching toward more than 20% annual return
Look at our spreadsheet right now (see table below), if bank loans us 90% of the purchase price, with the saving in furnishing cost and fees, the return of this apartment now jumps to 23.5%!
cashflow-projection13

This is not the end yet. We decided to ask banks to perform new valuation on the apartment instead of using its purchase price in order to maximise the loan amount. Several banks like Standard Chartered and CIMB banks came back to us and told us that, the value of this property is now between RM135,000 to RM150,000.

Based on banks’ valuations, we are able to loan at least RM120,000 from them. In return, we will be able to increase the return of this property to 29% since the loan amount is effectively 96% of the purchase price now (see table below)!!!
cashflow-projection34

Once we get the RM120,000 from bank, our cash capital will be reduced to RM24,625, and we still have a monthly cash flow of RM590. In other words, we will be collecting RM7080 from this property every year and within 3.5 years we should be able to take back all our cash capital RM24,625.

Of course, the above estimation is based on the assumption that the apartment will be continuously rented out. Also, tax on the rental income is not considered.

So, what do all these mean to you?
From this real life case, we demonstrated the three advantages of real estate investment to you as discussed in “Why real estate is a good investment?”:

1. Cash flow – we collect cash every month as a rental income from our rental property. In this case, we collect RM590 every month for a cash investment of RM24,625.
2. Leverage – we reduce our total cash capital by financing/refinancing our property and in return leverage the return. In this case, we improve the return on investment (ROI) from 8.5% to 29%.
3. Control – we actively control to increase the value and then the return of our investment property. In this case, we furnished the apartment so that it can be easily rented out for a higher rent and valued for a higher valuation.

(If you’re not already a subscriber to Real Estate Investment in Johor Bahru, subscribe here to receive our FREE latest update and articles via email.)

We write regularly about real estate investment. Some of our featured articles include:
“How to know if a property investment is worth investing?”
“How to estimate the value of a property?”
“How to find good real estate/property agents?”
“What must you know before buying auctioned properties?”
“Why apartment can be the best real estate investment?”

(Also, don’t forget to subscribe to our newsletter to receive a property investment evaluation tool. You can use this tool to estimate monthly cash flow, monthly installment and return on investment for your property. This tool will also show you if a property investment is worth borrowing/leveraging.)

Your comment and feedback on our posts are very much welcome. Please visit our blog posts to view other readers’ comments and write your feedback.

Related posts:

  1. Is it possible to have an infinite return on investment (or free money)?
  2. How to turn a property to become worth borrowing/leveraging?
  3. What risk you may face if you borrow too much and how to manage it?

{ 3 trackbacks }

How to turn a property to become worth borrowing/leveraging?
May 4, 2009 at 7:02 am
What risk you may face if you borrow too much and how to manage it?
May 15, 2009 at 6:32 am
Fact and Myth about Apartment Square Footage
August 25, 2009 at 6:40 am

{ 32 comments… read them below or add one }

1 CF April 23, 2009 at 9:08 am

This investment seems to generate enough Cashflow. However, for me, I doubt its possibility to generate similar amount of cashflow in the future. First, many (multinational) factories are likely to shift to Pasir Gudang (Iskandar Zone). Second, it is highly possible have to re-innovate the house or buying some new furniture in 5-10 years time to continue to attract the tenants, in order to get good rental. What do you think about this?

I also think that the average income for middle-class (eg: engineers) in Johor is not as high as KL. Their salary is probably RM 2XXX per month. How many of them are willing to spend big amount of money to rent GOOD apartment whereas they can use similar amount of money to buy a house. Would you like to give me your opinion?

Reply

2 ongkl April 24, 2009 at 9:50 am

Hi CF,

You are right, the average income for middle-class in Johor is not as high as KL, if they are working in Malaysia. We mostly target our apartments in JB to those who are working in Singapore. Imagaine, a fresh engineer working in Singapore gets paid at least S$2000 per month, that is RM4800 if he stays in JB! While renting a room only in Singapore will cost him at least S$450 every month.

We believe during the economy crisis, more and more Malaysian will come to JB and and look for jobs in Singapore, just like what had happened after the 1997 Asia currency crisis.

Cheers

Reply

3 KCLau April 23, 2009 at 9:17 am

This is a very useful case study that I believe will open the eyes of many people who still haven’t invest in properties.

Reply

4 雷門 April 23, 2009 at 12:55 pm

Thanks! Good sharing!

Reply

5 Kent April 23, 2009 at 5:03 pm

Good sharing, I’ve learned many things in this case, thank you very much.

Reply

6 CF April 24, 2009 at 10:04 am

Hi ongkl,

You are absolutely right.

Would mind sharing your experience in property management?
-Do you manage by yourself and use service from Property Management company? I heard that they charge about 4% of rental for the service fee.
-How do you calculate the future expenses on renovation and buying furniture.

Your article gives so much ‘number’ which is very meaningful. Thank you.

Reply

7 ongkl April 25, 2009 at 3:04 am

Hi CF,

- We currently manage our properties by ourselves.
- To calculate future expenses of renovation and furniture, we need to estimate the life span of existing furniture, fix & fittings, etc, and inflation rate. Multiply the existing costs with the product of inflation rate and the estimated life span. For example, a furniture that costs RM1000 now with a life span of 5 years, requires a replacing cost of RM1150 if we assume inflation rate at 3% flat every year.

We are glad that you guys like this article. We will share more real cases in future.

Cheers

Reply

8 XF April 24, 2009 at 11:38 pm

this is one of the rare few meaningful posts i’ve seen for a long time! thanks a great deal! :)

Reply

9 boonseng April 25, 2009 at 7:30 am

What is your view in term of capital appreciation for this property? Someone say apartment cannot appreciate as fast as landed property. Some example in KL Eg Taman Tun Dr Ismail purchase for RM 275,000 in year 2001 has now appreciate to RM 450,000 in year 2009. That is 70% return within 8 years. Most people nowadays try to get both, appreciation of value and rental.

Reply

10 ongkl April 27, 2009 at 10:35 am

Hi Boonseng,

In termof capital appreciation for this property, there is not much high side. Last year there were 8 transactions ranging between RM120k-RM170k. Recently we have some enquiries offered up to RM150k.

This kind of middle range apartments are not expected to get aggresive appreciation as the demand is mainly come from middle working class.

Cheers

Reply

11 HO April 26, 2009 at 12:23 pm

Hi ongKL,

Thanks for your good post. There are several questions for you:
1. are you a full time investor? how can you spare your time in managing so many properties…especially if you have many.

2. What’s your view in shop houses investment? It can generate rental income and capital appreciation.

Thanks,
HO

Reply

12 ongkl April 27, 2009 at 10:44 am

Hi Ho,

Yes I am a full time investor. Managing many properties may not as time consuming as we think if we know how to make use of Other People’s Time (OPT). If you have a team of people like agent, contractors, lawyers and bankers to help you, all you need most of the time is just to make a couple of calls to let them know your decisions. Your team membes will help you to execute your decisions.

Shop houses investment require more study on the location and future town plan of the area which make the risk in such investment higher than residential properties. Their return and appreciation can be very high if you have chosen the right property. It can be a disaster if things happen otherwise.

Cheers

Reply

13 Lee April 26, 2009 at 3:49 pm

For a property with market value of only RM125k to generate a monthly rental income of RM1300 is really not easy in JB market. To get a tenant who is willing to fork out RM1.3k for this type of apartment in Tampoi area is even harder.

Reply

14 ongkl April 27, 2009 at 11:04 am

Hi Lee,

It may be our luck to find this (in fact two) tenant for this property, but we rather believe it’s the mission that we hold on to and the effort from all our team members that bring this luck to us.

Almost every contractor and agent asked us the same question: “You furnish this property for you own stay or for rent?”
We answered: “For rent.”
They said: “I have never seen people furnish their rental property to such extent, is it really worth it?”
We always replied: “It’s more than whether it’s worth it or not. We like every single person who comes into the properties feels like to stay in it, even ourselves.”

We believe everyone deserves a nice place to stay, even just for a short time. And this is definitly much greater than all the numbers, dollar and cent that tell us worth it or not.

Cheers

Reply

15 nd April 28, 2009 at 12:58 pm

hello…
if u really looking for properties for invesment,why dont u look
at the new place with a good potentials. you can buy two units of properties for example
shop offices in eastcoast compared kl or jb.their rental also high depend on the location.
i have a double storey shop office for sale.their location is very strategic with 1000 units completed house. if u want to know detail just mail me

Reply

16 Jason Han Joo Kwong April 28, 2009 at 3:03 pm

My ID from Cari is jasonhanjk

This is the same apartment I am buying.
Sale price 100k, loan 100k.

Reply

17 ongkl May 2, 2009 at 9:57 pm

Hi Jason,

Congratulation. We have to say you did get a good price for this apartment.

Cheers

Reply

18 jasonhanjk May 2, 2009 at 11:35 pm

Thanks.

I will start looking for 2nd property in this area.
About 10 years ago, the previous landlord bought this apartment at around 160k.
Price has came down since then, until this area start booming again at 2007.

Many bargains are on the way.
My previous deal that I lose is a low cost flat.
Sell price 42k, rental 380.
The reason I lost it is because my pay is too high for low cost, hence losing RM1110 for government application.
Today the unit is still available and the rental went up to RM450.

Good luck on your loan, I manage to get 100k of the 120k, way less than the 90%.

Cheers.

Reply

19 Esa May 15, 2009 at 7:18 am

Hin Ong,

I have no doubt it can be done. With right knowledge of course. I am an avid reader/follower of your articles. Thanks so much for the informative articles.

If we are serious about property investment what would be you advice if an individual
has 5-6 condos as LHDN will treat the income as rental income not business income?
Meaning an individual will loose out a lot unlike sdn bhd company with the same number
of properties.

To transfer the properties to a company will also cost money. So it is a catch 20-20.
Grateful for your advice.

Reply

20 ongkl May 15, 2009 at 10:46 am

Hi Esa,

To evaluate which option can save you most, you need to compare the total expenses involved in both options with the total income tax that you need to pay in each option. You can ask a tax consultant to evalute for you and you can easily find one from any accounting firm or corporate secretary firm.

If your current personal income tax is below 20% bracket (after including all rental income), don’t consider to hold your properties under company since corporate tax is at least 20% (for annual profit below RM500k).

If the total expenses (operating and transfer cost) involved are much more higher than the tax that you can save from corporate tax, it is better also you own the properties under individual name.

If you have reached the maximum personal income tax bracket (27%), and the difference of 7% (between personal income tax and corporate tax) is greater than the total expenses to run a company, then you should hold your properties under a sdn bhd company.

Cheers

Reply

21 Kevin May 15, 2009 at 9:47 am

This is a nice case study, thanks for sharing…

Reply

22 kelvin June 7, 2009 at 11:31 pm

Hi Ongkl, i has been working in construction industry for 6 years but i’m only a begineer in property investment, thank you for your sharing.. hope to see more article. thanks

regards

Reply

23 wong June 21, 2009 at 8:22 am

hi,i want to ask persiaran tanjung at tampoi is good area for invest or not.the price is Rm125000.thanks

Reply

24 ongkl June 22, 2009 at 5:10 pm

Hi wong,

RM125k is a bit high unless it’s very well furnished.

Cheers

Reply

25 Andrew July 11, 2009 at 6:15 pm

Not sure how u managed to get RM1300 as I just looked up someone from adpost is renting Sri Wangi Tampoi at RM700 (1 floor above yours). That creates 2 questions:

1. the risk of tenant default rent upon realise the vast different from market price.
2. the better choice of sub-letting rooms of the existing property.

I like to invite anyone to discuss No.2

Reply

26 jasonhanjk July 14, 2009 at 11:17 pm

Andrew, there is a price difference from fully furnish and non furnish rental apartments.

Reply

27 Melvin July 30, 2009 at 12:36 am

Hi Ongkl, this is a great sharing, keep it up.
I’ve something want to ask, when you calculate your cashflow yield, don’t you take into consideration quit rent, assessments & insurance?
And as I’m from KL, which particular development offers such good yield? How to find them? So far at most is about 9% rental yield.

Reply

28 ongkl July 30, 2009 at 9:58 pm

Hi Melvin,

Quit rent, assessments & insurance are taken into monthly maintenance cost.

If you understand the market and prepare yourself with the fundamental of real estate investment, what you nee to do is to look for more property agents to help you find the good deals. They will base on your requirements to hunt the deals for you. Just make sure you give them the right requirements.

Cheers

Reply

29 Melvin July 31, 2009 at 1:11 am

ya, perhaps I’ve not got enough property agents to hunt the deals for me. So far what they’ve proposed is only about 8-9%. Some worse, even after giving them my spec, still propose something around 7% or less, as though they don’t understand ENglish.

Reply

30 powerkickers January 20, 2010 at 11:27 pm

Good Article!

Possible to send me your excel spreadsheet?

Thanks!

Reply

31 sky March 24, 2010 at 11:56 am

Hi Ongkl,

Thanks for providing a new angle of view in property investment in JB amidst all the bad comments from Condos perspective.

I am a strong believer that Singapore as a whole would be the biggest market for property investment in JB. With the fact that Singapore government envision an increase of population by 20-30% in the next 3-5 years.

I am currently in plan to secure a condos for myself (I am a Malaysian working in Singapore) and at the same time looking for alternative investment. However there’s this hurdle that constantly bugs my mind.

How do you factor management quality into consideration? From my point of view its more like a hit-or-miss equation based on luck. Also, it’d be great if you could input some comments on Danga View (280k bumilot) and Sri Samudera(280-300k 718sqf).
Thank you!

Reply

32 annie April 12, 2010 at 6:31 pm

hi..ong ” i want to buy apartment at Desa Tebrau>PLENITUDE, at price of 174k bcause i m bumiputra ,may i know more about this place do u think this is a good area to invest .Thk u

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post: Free eMoney Tips ebook (April 2009 Edition)

Next post: Is economy on her way of recovery?